“The service is fabulous, the baristas are welcoming and knowledgeable about their products. The atmosphere is warm and comfortable. The cakes are delicious and they have an assortment which made it hard to choose. I loved the little touches from the decor to offering blankets if you get cold. I will definitely be visiting again.”
“First time visiting the buttered cat today. Amazing little place. Lots of selection on the menu — there is something for everyone. Great selection of coffee, cold drinks and food, and plenty of sweet treats to choose from. The staff were really friendly and welcoming. Will definitely be back.”
“It was lovely. I got a Christmas panini and a chocolate milkshake — both were really good. I'd had a wander around town, the castle, then Tullie House, and then I was looking for somewhere to sit down. Saw on Facebook they were serving the Christmas menu and decided to give it a try. Really glad I did.”
“Amazing service, great atmosphere, really attentive chilled staff.”
“This place really is a gem — tasty food, tasty coffee and some awesome milkshakes.”
“The best coffee shop in Carlisle. Great selection of milkshakes and cakes.”
Comments reproduced from our Google reviews. Read them all on Google — where we were rated 4.8 from 148 reviews when we last checked, on 9 September 2026.
Come and see for yourself
Reviews only tell you so much — the best way to get it is to visit.
Been to The Buttered Cat?
We'd love to hear what you thought. Leave us a review on Google — it takes less than a minute and means the world to a small independent cafe.
Awards
We don't chase awards. The one below is recognition we can point you straight at, from the people who gave it.
Best Coffee Shop 2025
News & Star · 2025
Voted Best Coffee Shop 2025 by readers of the News & Star, with the winner announced on 12 December 2025.
Read the announcementIn the press
News & Star · March 2024
Covered The Buttered Cat's opening day in Kinmont Arcade, which the cafe described as “super amazing”.
Read the articleCome and say hello
In Kinmont Arcade, part of the historic Treasury Court in Carlisle city centre. Pop in for a coffee — we're open seven days a week.