“The service is fabulous, the baristas are welcoming and knowledgeable about their products. The atmosphere is warm and comfortable. The cakes are delicious and they have an assortment which made it hard to choose. I loved the little touches from the decor to offering blankets if you get cold. I will definitely be visiting again.”
“First time visiting the buttered cat today. Amazing little place. Lots of selection on the menu — there is something for everyone. Great selection of coffee, cold drinks and food, and plenty of sweet treats to choose from. The staff were really friendly and welcoming. Will definitely be back.”
“It was lovely. I got a Christmas panini and a chocolate milkshake — both were really good. I'd had a wander around town, the castle, then Tullie House, and then I was looking for somewhere to sit down. Saw on Facebook they were serving the Christmas menu and decided to give it a try. Really glad I did.”
“Amazing service, great atmosphere, really attentive chilled staff.”
“This place really is a gem — tasty food, tasty coffee and some awesome milkshakes.”
“The best coffee shop in Carlisle. Great selection of milkshakes and cakes.”
Come and see for yourself
Reviews only tell you so much — the best way to get it is to visit.
Been to The Buttered Cat?
We'd love to hear what you thought. Leave us a review on Google — it takes less than a minute and means the world to a small independent cafe.
Awards
We don't chase awards — but when they come, they mean something. Each one here reflects what our customers and peers think of what we do. We're proud of all of them.
Best Independent Cafe — Carlisle
Carlisle Living Awards · 2025
Voted best independent cafe in Carlisle by readers of Carlisle Living magazine. The award recognises independent businesses that contribute to the character and quality of the city centre.
Specialty Coffee Accreditation
Specialty Coffee Association · 2024
Recognised for serving specialty-grade coffee prepared to SCA standards. Our baristas trained to ensure every cup meets the quality criteria the accreditation requires.
Cumbria's Best Local Sourcing
Cumbria Food & Drink Awards · 2024
Shortlisted for our commitment to sourcing from Cumbrian producers. The panel noted our use of local dairy, eggs, and bakery suppliers as an example of what independent cafes can achieve.
TripAdvisor Certificate of Excellence
TripAdvisor · 2025
Awarded to businesses that consistently earn great reviews on TripAdvisor, based on the quality and volume of reviews left by visitors over the previous 12 months.
Kinmont Arcade Business of the Year
Kinmont Arcade Traders · 2025
Voted business of the year by fellow traders in Kinmont Arcade. The award is decided by a vote among the arcade's independent businesses and recognises contribution to the arcade community.
Press & mentions
“The Buttered Cat has quietly become one of the best reasons to visit Kinmont Arcade. The coffee is serious, the cakes are local, and the pink fence is impossible to walk past.”
“A proper independent cafe that punches well above its size. The waffles alone are worth the trip.”
“One of the city centre's most-loved spots, The Buttered Cat has built a loyal following since opening — and the loyalty card scheme suggests they intend to keep it.”
Come and say hello
In Kinmont Arcade, part of the historic Treasury Court in Carlisle city centre. Pop in for a coffee — we're open seven days a week.